Quote: (arkturas @ Oct. 02 2009, 11:48 )
Is spawning perceived to be better than it actually is?
In my readings, it really seems to be. ÂÂ
People talk about the hordes of Carnifex brought back and the game-breaking return of Hierodules and such, but I think those just stand out in people's minds despite their statistical rarity, *especially* if it wrecked the opponent's plans or won a game.
But for the most part, in the heat of battle, you've got a 66% chance of *not* spawning an AV back.  Sure, you can have some kind of "Blitz guard" sitting there getting bigger and bigger, but that's only if the enemy leaves you alone, and, to me, that seems *appropriately* Tyranidy.
In my games, spawning has been a light "boost" and not "game-breaking" in any fashion.  And it's *not* always the right choice to spawn back big things, sometimes you need the "bulk" of three Gaunts.
And in regard to "Tyrant Guard", they already exist in the list: 1) As the Hive Tyrant's tough stats, 2) "Counts as" using Carnifex.  Or were people seriously asking for an *additional* "Look out sir!"-type of special rule for them?