I tried that without knowing RichardL NOR my opponent.
It kind of blew up in my face. I even messed up the list (one of each, not three of each allowed) and ended up with a broken BTS. Hence my gratitude for you advice, guys! Epic Guard are a new army to me and I'm way out of my depth on this one but while it'd be great to win I'd at least like to give to my opponent a run for money/fair challenge!
Chatting on the phone to a friend tonight we compared Epic to Future War Commander. He introduced me to Epic and has been defeating me consistently as I get out-listed in Epic all the time. He's someone I've been playing both EA and FWC with for a couple for years now. First FWC game we had he was very surprised when he put at entire company of infantry safely in a building and I....well....I just kind of shot up the building and killed his company. In FWC it works, in Epic it doesn't, in the real world that's how battle are fought.
Why? Because that's how real armies fight. "This is Alpha. Bravo? There's an entire cpy in building XYZ? Give me a gravel beach in 2 minutes or I'll have your children's kidneys, soldier. Alpha Out"
The feedback I've received both on and offline from people I play is not that I play badly, it's that I'm out-listed. Epic is a game of chess with dice. I've yet to figure Epic out. I will. I'm just used to playing a different type of game and my vision as a man of the military doesn't work in EA. I have to backup and forget what I think I know about how battles are fought and actually just play the rules. The rules are what matter in E:A and I have to read them, learn them, and stop playing wargames. After all, there aren't that many rules. This isn't Panzer War or Spearhead. Most of my books are lists after all.
Clipping is something it's taken me two years to get my head around. Still get clipped all the time and can't figure out neither how people pull it off nor how to do it myself. According to contemporary military doctrine, clipping attacks are impossible. But I want to play E:A so I've to to figure it out!
Monday night I learned you can break a formation just by defeating it in close combat.
AWESOME! Unrealistic, but what I found really realistic was shooting at a broken formation annihilates that formation. THAT makes sense to me.
I really want to play Epic Armageddon, love the 40k universe, but as an historical Ancients-Cold War 1/300 player I find Epic
gamey sometimes.
Living in Australia, though, this is what people play, so I'm happy to conform. No issues at all.
Do I find it interesting 11 RA tanks can be broken by 4 stands of petty Eldar scouts? I do.
Should I learn the rules better? Absolutely!!
Love this list you guys have suggested. I'd still an airmobile in there, maybe instead of a hydra on the arty and dropping something here and there, but I won't know till I play.
Much love and thank you for your amazing advice!
I want to make EA work for me. Marines I'm ok with, Eldar I can't win with to save my skin, ANYONE can win with Necrons, and 'Nids aren't allowed. I know how to fight Orks (with Marines) and other matchups are 50/50 (when I know what I'm doing I'm actually not that bad....)