To your specific questions
carlisimo109 wrote:
The most basic of our questions is… what’s with all the lists?? We’ve been looking at the official lists, but have come across the tweaked EpicUK lists. How many people use them outside of tournaments in the UK? Would you recommend using them? For now, we’re just going to be playing friendly games in the US…. And I’m probably not going to touch the NetEA lists because that seems to be a completely different game.
I think I answered this above. Epic-UK lists tend to be used in UK competitons, other communities have their 'favourite' lists, and there are quite a number of home-grown variations. Be aware that the points system provided is really intended for the 'tournament scenario'. Note lists are really there to provide some framework to a given situation and you are encouraged to develop your own themes.
carlisimo109 wrote:
With the years of accumulated advice on this forum, I don’t think I need too much more help on list creation, other than to ask about characters. What’s a good number – 2 or 3 in a 3,000pt army? Would you use a squad without a character in a different way? Captains don’t seem very common in other people’s SM lists, but it seems to be they’d be useful if you have both bike and assault squads in your army – should I?.
Characters enable the Marines to rally better (Leader removes an additional BM) and to control the formation better in one respect. Commander is probably the hardest to use (and thus the least seen), but allows small marine formations to be combined to take on a much larger enemy like an entrenched IG company. There is no hard and fast rule on numbers - it is down to personal choice and your intended army strategy.
carlisimo109 wrote:
My friend is struggling more with his IG list because of its limits (2 support formations per company, a number of vehicle types only available as upgrades or in large formations…). He likes Stormtroopers and artillery, and his early lists contain little else. I’m a little worried that we’re going to have one-dimensional battles. Sorry, at this point I’m just ranting. Actual IG question now – does a Commissar’s fearless ability do anything useful if it isn’t in a single-unit formation? And any thoughts on how to assemble a reasonable Stormtrooper-heavy list?
Stormtroopers by themselves are quite weak, but become much more usefull when given transport and support (Valkyries and Vultures). This allows the IG to create an 'Arnhem' style scenario of a forward assault supported by a mechanised support and artillery.
And no it won't be one-dimensional because your Marines can provide a flexible response with a focussed air-assault on particualr points of the battlefield to support beleagured garrisons - and there is no reason why you shouldn't play with mixed armies :- IG with some marine allies vs Marines with Navy support . . .But I am getting ahead of myself - master the basics first and foremost and above all,
HAVE FUN